Context
Epic #11558 includes ADR and general documentation references after the policy, lint, AGENTS maps, and skill partitions are defined. This final partition handles non-skill documentation without collapsing active references and historical archaeology into the same treatment.
The Problem
ADR and documentation files can contain positional §N references with different meanings: some are live guidance references that should migrate, while others are historical references to the state at the time of a decision. Treating both classes identically risks either stale live guidance or damaged archaeology.
The Architectural Reality
Discussion #11557 v5 and Gemini cycle-4 StepBack require an active-vs-archive boundary. Historical/archaeology refs either preserve original numbering intentionally or get an explicit errata class. Live documentation refs should use semantic anchors once the policy and map anchors exist.
The Fix
Audit and migrate ADR / documentation references according to the semantic-anchor policy from #11559:
- live guidance references migrate to semantic anchors
- historical/archaeology references are preserved intentionally with classification or errata
- no broad prose rewrites unrelated to reference identity
Discussion Criteria Mapping
- OQ1 historical/archaeology refs -> preserve intentionally or classify as errata.
- Active/archive boundary -> this ticket owns non-skill docs treatment.
- Migration blast-radius partial -> bounded docs/ADR partition with explicit evidence.
- OQ6 ADR vehicle -> depends on policy ADR from #11559.
Acceptance Criteria
Out of Scope
- Migrating skill files.
- Changing ADR decisions beyond reference mechanics and explicit errata.
- Reopening old architectural decisions.
Avoided Traps / Gold Standards Rejected
- Blind global search-and-replace is rejected because historical references need archaeological context.
- Leaving stale live refs because they appear in docs is rejected; live guidance still participates in Option C.
Related
Origin Session ID: 6e5b995a-c68e-4179-840c-a4cc48d449da
Retrieval Hint: "ADR docs semantic anchors historical archaeology active archive boundary #11558"
Context
Epic #11558 includes ADR and general documentation references after the policy, lint, AGENTS maps, and skill partitions are defined. This final partition handles non-skill documentation without collapsing active references and historical archaeology into the same treatment.
The Problem
ADR and documentation files can contain positional
§Nreferences with different meanings: some are live guidance references that should migrate, while others are historical references to the state at the time of a decision. Treating both classes identically risks either stale live guidance or damaged archaeology.The Architectural Reality
Discussion #11557 v5 and Gemini cycle-4 StepBack require an active-vs-archive boundary. Historical/archaeology refs either preserve original numbering intentionally or get an explicit errata class. Live documentation refs should use semantic anchors once the policy and map anchors exist.
The Fix
Audit and migrate ADR / documentation references according to the semantic-anchor policy from #11559:
Discussion Criteria Mapping
Acceptance Criteria
Out of Scope
Avoided Traps / Gold Standards Rejected
Related
Origin Session ID: 6e5b995a-c68e-4179-840c-a4cc48d449da Retrieval Hint: "ADR docs semantic anchors historical archaeology active archive boundary #11558"