#14499 (Resolves #13432) shipped ADR-19 violations that crashed the live orchestrator and were missed in review by both reviewers (@neo-opus-ada + @neo-opus-grace). Reverting to restore a known-good dev; #13432 will be re-delivered ADR-19-compliant on a clean base.
Damage (V-B-A'd against code, per @neo-opus-ada's diagnosis):
- Class 1 — §2.1 hierarchy non-participation (the crash).
initServerConfigs.mjs reads aiConfig.auth.mode bare, but NL / non-memory-core server configs do not import the Tier-1 realm root, so their getParent() chain has no root → auth is undefined → TypeError → orchestrator/NL bridge crash. My review RA-1 ("drop the defensive ?. on aiConfig.auth") removed the mask over this non-participation without fixing participation first — sequence-inverted.
- Class 2 — §3 B5 pass-along. Daemons thread the SSOT root (
assertConfigFresh({aiConfig: AiConfig})) instead of the guard reading the resolved leaf at its own use-site.
Disposition: revert now (stop the live crash) → co-driven ADR-19 audit → compliant #13432 re-do (participation-first, no threading, no B3 ?.) → elevate the AGENTS.md ADR-19 read-gate to CRITICAL. Re-opens #13432.
#14499 (Resolves #13432) shipped ADR-19 violations that crashed the live orchestrator and were missed in review by both reviewers (@neo-opus-ada + @neo-opus-grace). Reverting to restore a known-good
dev; #13432 will be re-delivered ADR-19-compliant on a clean base.Damage (V-B-A'd against code, per @neo-opus-ada's diagnosis):
initServerConfigs.mjsreadsaiConfig.auth.modebare, but NL / non-memory-core server configs do not import the Tier-1 realm root, so theirgetParent()chain has no root →authis undefined → TypeError → orchestrator/NL bridge crash. My review RA-1 ("drop the defensive?.onaiConfig.auth") removed the mask over this non-participation without fixing participation first — sequence-inverted.assertConfigFresh({aiConfig: AiConfig})) instead of the guard reading the resolved leaf at its own use-site.Disposition: revert now (stop the live crash) → co-driven ADR-19 audit → compliant #13432 re-do (participation-first, no threading, no B3
?.) → elevate the AGENTS.md ADR-19 read-gate to CRITICAL. Re-opens #13432.