LearnNewsExamplesServices
Frontmatter
id14842
titleROADMAP cornerstone 4 cites retired epic 14564 — drop the anchor + measurement framing
stateClosed
labels
documentationenhancementai
assigneesneo-gpt
createdAt11:56 AM
updatedAt1:46 PM
githubUrlhttps://github.com/neomjs/neo/issues/14842
authorneo-fable-clio
commentsCount0
parentIssuenull
subIssues[]
subIssuesCompleted0
subIssuesTotal0
contentTrust
projected
quarantined0
signals[]
blockedBy[]
blocking[]
closedAt1:46 PM

ROADMAP cornerstone 4 cites retired epic 14564 — drop the anchor + measurement framing

Closed Backlog/active-chunk-4 documentationenhancementai
neo-fable-clio
neo-fable-clio commented on 11:56 AM

Context

Operator-ordered (2026-07-05, live session), from the #14564 retirement: the epic and its measurement sub-series were closed on the operator's verdict — Agent OS ships into client clouds without us, so install-measurement harnesses measure deployments we have no access to, and the framing gated CREATE-work behind measurement theater. Full disposition: the closure comment on #14564. ROADMAP.md still carries the dead anchor and its framing.

The Problem

ROADMAP.md's v13.2 cornerstone 4 ("Self-configuring Agent OS + onboarding") anchors #14564 and states the done signal as "TTFP-in-minutes and fork→PR ≤ 30 min, measured by the acceptance harness, not claimed" — a bar whose harness leaves (#14672/#14676/#14673) are now closed as zero-value. The release gate paragraph (line ~13) carries the same leak: "it self-configures to first persistence in minutes" framed toward a stranger-download measurement story.

The Architectural Reality

  • ROADMAP.md:24 — the cornerstone 4 table row (anchors + done signal).
  • ROADMAP.md:13 — the compound gate sentence.
  • Surviving anchor: #14230 (local-first developer onboarding — fork → install → try a lane → PR): real, local, CREATE-shaped.
  • Surviving standalone leaf from the retirement: #14674 (template exports an extendable base — overlay-drift root fix); optionally citable under the cornerstone if the row survives in reduced form.
  • ROADMAP is next-release-scope-only substrate; edits ride a normal PR to dev.

The Fix

One PR editing ROADMAP.md only:

  1. Cornerstone 4 row: drop the #14564 anchor; anchor on #14230 (+ optionally #14674); rewrite the done signal in CREATE terms — the operator's bar phrased as working behavior (a fresh clone reaches first persistence without hand-editing config), no "measured by harness" clause.
  2. Gate paragraph: keep the stranger bar's substance, strip the measurement framing where it references the retired harness series.
  3. Nothing else moves — cornerstones 1/2/3/5, sequencing prose, and the deferred set stay byte-identical.

Acceptance Criteria

  • No reference to #14564 or its closed subs remains in ROADMAP.md.
  • Cornerstone 4's done signal is stated as working local behavior, not a measurement deliverable.
  • Diff touches ROADMAP.md only; all other cornerstones byte-identical.
  • Cross-family review (author is GPT-family → any Claude-family reviewer qualifies).

Out of Scope

Re-scoping #14230 · reviving any retired leaf · the D#14561 fold record (historical, stays).

Related

#14564 (retired epic — the disposition of record) · #14230 · #14674 · #14601 (the prior v13.2 roadmap-replacement precedent). Live latest-open sweep: latest 10 at 2026-07-05T09:57Z, no equivalent. Assigned per operator direction: @neo-gpt. Origin Session ID: 7f091625-81ac-41f7-af1b-f902bf313560 Retrieval Hint: "roadmap cornerstone 4 retired 14564 measurement framing drop"

tobiu referenced in commit 48dea48 - "docs(roadmap): drop retired config measurement anchor (#14842) (#14843)" on 1:46 PM
tobiu closed this issue on 1:46 PM