Rescope 2026-11-08 (operator context, Vega). The plane owns the concept graph, and Brain's generators enhance it (A2A parsing among them). Today's concepts mostly came from guide names. Deleting the engine copy cannot touch plane data, so a diverging row no longer blocks the deletion: the one diverging edge from the 2026-11-06 comparison is recorded on neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471 for the plane to take. AC-4 is dropped as a merge gate.
Rescope 2026-11-06 (householding, Vega).
Delivered and met: the Markdown half left with neomjs/neo#19159 (PR neomjs/neo#19322). The pin-route prerequisite was met by neomjs/neo-agent-brain#1356, not neomjs/neo-agent-brain#474. The orchestrator reads plane.dataRoot/concepts, and no org repository reads the engine copy (grep at Engine 268b527d30, Brain ac4320fd, Institution 0b77645, Skills 69782b6, Stage 0f98bfa).
Blocked: what remains is .neo-ai-data/concepts/ and its package surface, and AC-1 blocks it. Against the newest plane bundle (backup 2026-11-06T14:51Z), 65 of 65 nodes and 181 of 182 edges are field-identical. The one conflict is dream-pipeline IMPLEMENTED_BY. The engine copy says file:src/evolution/RemDigestion.mjs, corrected by neomjs/neo#19236 on 2026-09-26. The plane still says file:ai/daemons/orchestrator/services/DreamService.mjs, a file the Brain no longer has. The engine row is the right one, so the plane takes it first; neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471 records that correction.
Context
neomjs/neo#19096 graduated option E′ into neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471: concepts are tenant-scoped plane data, and neomjs is one instance of that mechanism. This ticket was the provisional shell for the engine's half. Under E′ the engine copies are imported, which is a no-op while they are equal, and then deleted, never moved. Roadmap cornerstone 3 (#17416) ends with the engine no longer carrying the resources/content mirror, and this is that family's leaf.
The Problem
The engine still carries both halves of neomjs' concepts:
- The explanations: 59 files in
resources/content/concepts/, under a root that ADR 0004 §1.3 defines as a regeneratable cache and that neomjs/neo#19159 deletes.
- The graph copy:
nodes.jsonl (65 rows) and edges.jsonl (182) at .neo-ai-data/concepts/. It is a strict, field-identical subset of the plane store, per @neo-opus-ada's row-by-row check (neomjs/neo#19096 fact 9), and the npm package ships it.
The Architectural Reality
- The copies are equal today. 59 docs against 65 nodes: 0 missing, 0 mismatches (@neo-gpt, DC 18565631). The engine JSONL holds 65 of 65 nodes and 182 of 182 edges, field-identical to the plane store.
- Package surface (@neo-opus-grace's
STEP_BACK, point 2):
.gitignore:108 negates .neo-ai-data/concepts/. No .npmignore is committed: prepack composes it from .gitignore (buildScripts/util/npmIgnoreComposition.mjs), so that one negation is also the package's.
buildScripts/util/check-package-contents.mjs:59 allows it.
test/playwright/unit/buildScripts/checkPackageContents.spec.mjs (L46–47, L133–134) and gitignoreNegationReachability.spec.mjs (L161) pin it.
- (Re-measured on
dev 2026-11-06 from @neo-gpt-sophie's corrections: the earlier .npmignore:140 negation and check-chore-sync.mjs:102 are gone, the latter deleted with #19322.)
- No engine code reads either copy. The content-root guard baseline (#19167) has no concept rows. The Brain's interim route over the engine pin retired with neomjs/neo-agent-brain#1356.
The Fix
Equality receipt, taken at execution time. Compare each engine node by id, and each edge by source|target|type, with the newest plane bundle. The Markdown files are gone, and the JSONL rows carry the same descriptions.
- If they are equal, the import is a no-op.
- Any difference is a source-authority conflict. Report it; never let a frozen engine file overwrite a newer plane description.
Delete, never move:
resources/content/concepts/ (59 files), delivered by neomjs/neo#19159;
.neo-ai-data/concepts/ (2 files).
The PR re-runs the id-by-id comparison against the newest bundle and prints the counts as its receipt.
Package surface. Remove the .gitignore negation, the allow entry, and the spec cases that pin them.
Decision Record impact: aligned-with ADR 0004 §1.3; depends-on the ADR 0023 / 0024 amendment (neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472).
Decision Record: Required: neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472.
Acceptance Criteria
Discussion Criteria Mapping
G4 → AC-1 to AC-4. The Epic neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471 carries the graduation's Signal Ledger, Unresolved Dissent, Unresolved Liveness and full mapping.
Out of Scope
- The other
resources/content families (the other blockers of neomjs/neo#19159, such as neomjs/neo#19157).
- The Brain-side route (neomjs/neo-agent-brain#474).
- The legacy concept vectors (neomjs/neo-agent-brain#419).
unowned-rationale: blocked by the plane's stale dream-pipeline edge (AC-1, AC-4). Whoever lands that plane correction claims it.
Related
neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471 (the graduated Epic) · neomjs/github-content-sync#26 (parent) · neomjs/neo#19159 (blocked) · neomjs/neo#19096 · neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472 · neomjs/neo-agent-brain#474 · neomjs/neo#11373 · ADR 0004 §1.3
Update 2026-09-24 20:40Z: promoted at graduation. It was a provisional shell, [PROVISIONAL_UNGRADUATED: D#19096], with a destination still to be decided. It is now the deletion leaf of option E′. The divergence table moved to the source Discussion, and A–D were rejected there.
Origin Session ID: db85836e-f7c2-4da0-a614-fa0e93e8e727 (filed) · 9f7b8241-8b3c-4954-a9e5-2f9c1e41d669 (promoted)
Retrieval Hint: query_raw_memories("concept files resources/content/concepts delete engine JSONL copy equality receipt package surface D#19096")
Authored by Vega (Opus 5.5, Claude Code) 🌿
Context
neomjs/neo#19096 graduated option E′ into neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471: concepts are tenant-scoped plane data, and neomjs is one instance of that mechanism. This ticket was the provisional shell for the engine's half. Under E′ the engine copies are imported, which is a no-op while they are equal, and then deleted, never moved. Roadmap cornerstone 3 (#17416) ends with the engine no longer carrying the
resources/contentmirror, and this is that family's leaf.The Problem
The engine still carries both halves of neomjs' concepts:
resources/content/concepts/, under a root that ADR 0004 §1.3 defines as a regeneratable cache and that neomjs/neo#19159 deletes.nodes.jsonl(65 rows) andedges.jsonl(182) at.neo-ai-data/concepts/. It is a strict, field-identical subset of the plane store, per @neo-opus-ada's row-by-row check (neomjs/neo#19096 fact 9), and the npm package ships it.The Architectural Reality
STEP_BACK, point 2):.gitignore:108negates.neo-ai-data/concepts/. No.npmignoreis committed:prepackcomposes it from.gitignore(buildScripts/util/npmIgnoreComposition.mjs), so that one negation is also the package's.buildScripts/util/check-package-contents.mjs:59allows it.test/playwright/unit/buildScripts/checkPackageContents.spec.mjs(L46–47, L133–134) andgitignoreNegationReachability.spec.mjs(L161) pin it.dev2026-11-06 from @neo-gpt-sophie's corrections: the earlier.npmignore:140negation andcheck-chore-sync.mjs:102are gone, the latter deleted with #19322.)The Fix
Equality receipt, taken at execution time. Compare each engine node by
id, and each edge bysource|target|type, with the newest plane bundle. The Markdown files are gone, and the JSONL rows carry the same descriptions.Delete, never move:
resources/content/concepts/(59 files), delivered by neomjs/neo#19159;.neo-ai-data/concepts/(2 files).The PR re-runs the id-by-id comparison against the newest bundle and prints the counts as its receipt.
Package surface. Remove the
.gitignorenegation, the allow entry, and the spec cases that pin them.Decision Record impact: aligned-with ADR 0004 §1.3; depends-on the ADR 0023 / 0024 amendment (neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472). Decision Record: Required: neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472.
Acceptance Criteria
.neo-ai-data/concepts/is deleted (resources/content/concepts/already left with neomjs/neo#19159). The receipt is the 2026-11-06 id-by-id comparison against the newest plane bundle: 65 of 65 nodes and 181 of 182 edges, the one conflict named..neo-ai-data/concepts/:.gitignorenegation is removed (the published.npmignoreis composed from it, so there is no second copy);check-package-contentsallow entry is removed, along with the spec cases pinning it;check-package-contentspasses.AC-4 The PR merges once the plane carriesDropped 2026-11-08: the plane owns concepts, and the edge is recorded on neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471.dream-pipeline IMPLEMENTED_BY file:src/evolution/RemDigestion.mjs, so the receipt reads 182 of 182 edges. Both original prerequisites have landed: neomjs/neo-agent-brain#1356 retired the pin route, and neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472 amended the ADRs. The "before neomjs/neo#19159" ordering lapsed when neomjs/neo#19159 merged.Discussion Criteria Mapping
G4 → AC-1 to AC-4. The Epic neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471 carries the graduation's Signal Ledger, Unresolved Dissent, Unresolved Liveness and full mapping.
Out of Scope
resources/contentfamilies (the other blockers of neomjs/neo#19159, such as neomjs/neo#19157).unowned-rationale: blocked by the plane's stale
dream-pipelineedge (AC-1, AC-4). Whoever lands that plane correction claims it.Related
neomjs/neo-agent-brain#471 (the graduated Epic) · neomjs/github-content-sync#26 (parent) · neomjs/neo#19159 (blocked) · neomjs/neo#19096 · neomjs/neo-agent-brain#472 · neomjs/neo-agent-brain#474 · neomjs/neo#11373 · ADR 0004 §1.3
Origin Session ID: db85836e-f7c2-4da0-a614-fa0e93e8e727 (filed) · 9f7b8241-8b3c-4954-a9e5-2f9c1e41d669 (promoted) Retrieval Hint:
query_raw_memories("concept files resources/content/concepts delete engine JSONL copy equality receipt package surface D#19096")Authored by Vega (Opus 5.5, Claude Code) 🌿