Context
#20451 decides the fate of workstation/WorkstationFilmTourNL; #19919 was folded into it for that purpose. The spec's three arms run off-socket, so it is adapter-eligible. Its hosted record still keeps it out of the required engine tier, so PR #20584 declares it in EXCLUSIONS (buildScripts/util/e2eCiSelection.mjs), with this ticket as the owner.
The Problem
Hosted run 42461321072, PR #20584 at 70b1e0e, shard 1/14, where FilmTour runs alone:
- Attempt 1. The viewer-driven arm ("Start film tour runs all scenes…") failed at
WorkstationFilmTourNL.spec.mjs:255, "the momentum carried the rows at least as far again as the hand": observed.y was 474 against the required 2 × requested.y = 960. The probe line reads observed {x: 356, y: 474} for a throw of requested {x: 360, y: 480}. The rows moved only as far as the hand, so the release carried no momentum. In the same job, the autoGates arm's throw did carry it: observed {x: 732, y: 1133}.
- Attempt 2, a rerun of the shard. All three arms passed, and the throws read 1133 and 1051.
So one throw in four carried nothing.
Observation versus inference:
- Observed: the zero-momentum throw and its numbers.
- Inferred, not measured — the cause:
GridDragScroll#onDragEnd (src/main/addon/GridDragScroll.mjs:156-162) reads the release velocity from the moves of the last 100 ms (a Date.now() cutoff), and starts no momentum when fewer than two moves fall inside that window.
- The film's throw samples every 33 ms (
moveDelay: 33, moveSteps: 24, curve: 'throw', apps/workstation/tour/fiveBeatFilm.mjs:485), so about three samples sit in the window.
- A hosted stall of about 70 ms before the release would therefore leave fewer than two.
The Architectural Reality
- The throw.
GestureDriver#executeGridDragScrollStep (apps/workstation/tour/GestureDriver.mjs), whose quartic 'throw' curve puts the speed into the last samples.
- The momentum.
GridDragScroll#onDragEnd calls autoScroll, which applies friction of 0.95 per frame. The total travel is about 20× the release velocity whatever the frame rate, so only the release sampling depends on timing.
- The witness.
WorkstationFilmTourNL.spec.mjs:246-255 pins observed.y ≥ 2 × requested.y, as #19584 designed it ("because that is what the beat claims").
- The scope limit. #19584's Out of Scope excludes changing the addon or its friction.
The Fix
- Measure the release. On a hosted run, log the moves that fall inside the 100 ms window at the release; the film-probe line can carry them. That confirms or refutes the stall.
- If the stall is confirmed, make the throw's release land within the window even under a stall, without changing the addon. For example, the driver releases in the same task as its last sample, or tightens its last samples.
- After green hosted repeats, FilmTour leaves
EXCLUSIONS and rejoins RUN_PATHS.
Acceptance Criteria
Out of Scope
- The film's other beats, and the hop 4 classification (#19919).
- The off-socket adapter gaps (#20587).
Related
#20451 · PR #20584 · #19919 · #19584 · #15252
Ownership: self-assigned. It owns a CI exclusion entry.
Live latest-open + closed sweep: checked the latest 20 open issues and closed searches ("film tour momentum", "GridDragScroll velocity release") at 2026-11-08T08:19Z, and read the Out of Scope of the same-surface closed hit #19584. No equivalent or prior exclusion was found; the closed #18104, #18099 and #8916 cover the addon's own lifecycle. A2A in-flight sweep: the last 15 messages hold no claim on this surface. Memory Core sweep: no prior hosted-momentum finding. Own open assignments: #20587, #20451, #20328.
Origin Session ID: 03506c7d-003d-47bf-9c85-0c87a27e3213
Retrieval Hint: "film tour grid throw no momentum hosted runner GridDragScroll 100 ms release window"
Context
#20451 decides the fate of
workstation/WorkstationFilmTourNL; #19919 was folded into it for that purpose. The spec's three arms run off-socket, so it is adapter-eligible. Its hosted record still keeps it out of the required engine tier, so PR #20584 declares it inEXCLUSIONS(buildScripts/util/e2eCiSelection.mjs), with this ticket as the owner.The Problem
Hosted run 42461321072, PR #20584 at
70b1e0e, shard 1/14, where FilmTour runs alone:WorkstationFilmTourNL.spec.mjs:255, "the momentum carried the rows at least as far again as the hand":observed.ywas 474 against the required2 × requested.y= 960. The probe line readsobserved {x: 356, y: 474}for a throw ofrequested {x: 360, y: 480}. The rows moved only as far as the hand, so the release carried no momentum. In the same job, the autoGates arm's throw did carry it:observed {x: 732, y: 1133}.So one throw in four carried nothing.
Observation versus inference:
GridDragScroll#onDragEnd(src/main/addon/GridDragScroll.mjs:156-162) reads the release velocity from the moves of the last 100 ms (aDate.now()cutoff), and starts no momentum when fewer than two moves fall inside that window.moveDelay: 33,moveSteps: 24,curve: 'throw',apps/workstation/tour/fiveBeatFilm.mjs:485), so about three samples sit in the window.The Architectural Reality
GestureDriver#executeGridDragScrollStep(apps/workstation/tour/GestureDriver.mjs), whose quartic'throw'curve puts the speed into the last samples.GridDragScroll#onDragEndcallsautoScroll, which applies friction of 0.95 per frame. The total travel is about 20× the release velocity whatever the frame rate, so only the release sampling depends on timing.WorkstationFilmTourNL.spec.mjs:246-255pinsobserved.y ≥ 2 × requested.y, as #19584 designed it ("because that is what the beat claims").The Fix
EXCLUSIONSand rejoinsRUN_PATHS.Acceptance Criteria
WorkstationFilmTourNLpasses on 3 consecutive hosted engine-tier runs. It moves fromEXCLUSIONSback intoRUN_PATHS, with its measured duration (177.8 s) ine2eEngineDurations.json.GridDragScroll's velocity rule and friction stay unchanged, per #19584's scope, unless the measurement shows the rule is itself wrong for a real user.Out of Scope
Related
#20451 · PR #20584 · #19919 · #19584 · #15252
Ownership: self-assigned. It owns a CI exclusion entry.
Live latest-open + closed sweep: checked the latest 20 open issues and closed searches ("film tour momentum", "GridDragScroll velocity release") at 2026-11-08T08:19Z, and read the Out of Scope of the same-surface closed hit #19584. No equivalent or prior exclusion was found; the closed #18104, #18099 and #8916 cover the addon's own lifecycle. A2A in-flight sweep: the last 15 messages hold no claim on this surface. Memory Core sweep: no prior hosted-momentum finding. Own open assignments: #20587, #20451, #20328.
Origin Session ID: 03506c7d-003d-47bf-9c85-0c87a27e3213
Retrieval Hint: "film tour grid throw no momentum hosted runner GridDragScroll 100 ms release window"